Similac Pro Sensitive Vs All Gerber Good Start Formulas: Full Comparison

You are currently viewing Similac Pro Sensitive Vs All Gerber Good Start Formulas: Full Comparison

Similac Pro Sensitive is a sensitive formula designed for babies who have fussiness and gas caused by lactose sensitivity made from milk protein isolate and 1% lactose so the immune system won’t elicit negative responses. Moreover, it has an HMO’s prebiotic (2′-FL) to help develop the immune system and digestive health properly. Also, it has a blend of DHA, lutein, and vitamin E called OptiGro to promote brain, cell, and eye development.

According to moms’ reviews, it helps with fussiness and reflux and has good taste. However, it’s too foamy and may cause gas for some babies.

In this article, we will see a full comparison between Similac Pro Sensitive and all Gerber Good Start Formulas to choose the best alternative.

“When you buy something using my links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This is a kind of support to me. This website doesn’t accept money for reviews. “

Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start GentlePro:

Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start GentlePro

Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start GentlePro are lactose-reduced formulas but with different percentages; the latter is made of 70% lactose and 30% corn maltodextrin whereas Pro Sensitive has only 1% lactose, sugar, and corn syrup as carbohydrate sources. On the other hand, Gerber Good Start GentlePro uses a partially hydrolyzed whey protein to be gentle on babies’ tummies. In contrast, Pro Sensitive uses intact cow’s milk (milk protein isolate) with a whey-to-casein ratio of 18:82.

Furthermore, both formulas have the 2′-FL (Fucosyl Lactose) prebiotic that resembles the major one in breast milk (Human Milk Oligosaccharides, or HMOs) more than other prebiotics exist in baby formulas. This Prebiotic is food for probiotics (good bacteria), a happy probiotic will support the digestive health.

However, Good Start GentlePro has a probiotic called Bifidobacterium Lactis or B. Lactis (healthy bacteria) whereas Pro Sensitive doesn’t have. On the opposite side, the latter has the OptiGro Feature which is a blend of DHA, lutein, and vitamin E for the brain, cell, and eye development.

In terms of nutrients, Pro Sensitive is enriched with minerals more than GentlePro. In contrast, the latter is enriched with vitamins more than Pro Sensitive.

Moreover, Gerber Good Start GentlePro is cheaper (1.14 $/oz) than Pro Sensitive (1.24 $/oz).

Moms Reviews:

Similac Pro SensitiveGerber Good Start GentlePro
Positive
Reviews
Good for fussiness
Easy to digest
Good taste
Good for Gas
Easy to mix
Huge container
It has a scoop holder
Good taste
Negative
Reviews
May cause constipation
May cause gas
Too foamy
Not good for traveling
The scoop is too wide

The table below shows a complete comparison between Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start GentlePro in terms of ingredients, features, nutrient value, and price. For a better VIEW rotate your phone screen.

Similac Pro SensitiveGerber Good Start GentlePro
Protein sourceMilk Protein IsolatePartially hydrolyzed whey
protein concentrate
Whey to Casein Ratio18:82100% whey
Carbohydrate source 1% Lactose
Corn Syrup
Sugar
70% Lactose
30% Maltodextrin
Fat source– High Oleic Safflower Oil
– Soy Oil
– Coconut Oil
– DHA/ARA
38% Palm Oil
6% High Oleic Safflower Oil
35% Soy Oil
19% Coconut Oil
2% single cell oil
DHA/ARA
Extra FeaturesOptiGro
Prebiotics– 2′-FL HMO
Short-chain Fructooligosaccharides
2′-FL HMO
ProbioticsB. Lactis
Generic Brands7 Generic brands6 Generic brands
Protein (g)2.1 /100 Cal2.2 /100 Cal
Fat (g)5.4 /100 Cal5.1 /100 Cal
Carbohydrate (g)10.9 /100 Cal11.2 /100 Cal
Vitamin A (IU)300 /100 Cal300 /100 Cal
Vitamin D (IU)60 /100 Cal75 /100 Cal
Vitamin E (IU)1.5 /100 Cal2 /100 Cal
Vitamin C (mg)
(Ascorbic acid)
9 /100 Cal10 /100 Cal
Inositol (mg)24 /100 Cal6 /100 Cal
Calcium (mg)84 /100 Cal67 /100 Cal
Phosphorus (mg)56 /100 Cal38 /100 Cal
Iron (mg)1.8 /100 Cal1.5 /100 Cal
Zinc (mg)0.75 /100 Cal0.8 /100 Cal
Manganese (mcg)5 /100 Cal15 /100 Cal
Sodium (mg)30 /100 Cal27 /100 Cal
Source of ARAMortierella alpina oilMortierella alpina oil
Source of DHACrypthecodinium cohnii oilCrypthecodinium cohnii oil
Size and Price29.8 oz
36.96 $
1.24 /oz

32 fl oz
8.12$
25.4 ¢/fl oz
20 oz
29.24 $
1.46 /oz

32 oz
36.48 $
1.14 /oz


33.8 fl oz
8.74$
25.9 ¢/fl oz
Rating4.3 of 5.0
895 reviews
4.8 of 5.0
2519 reviews
Ready-to-feedYesYes
Where to Buy?Buy 29.8 oz HERE

Buy Ready-to-feed
Buy 20 oz HERE

Buy 32 oz HERE

Buy RTF HERE
Overall Note7.5/108/10
Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start GentlePro

Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start SoothePro:

Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start SoothePro

The difference between Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start SoothePro is that the latter contains a gentle whey protein partially hydrolyzed and contains 70% of lactose whereas Similac Pro Sensitive is lactose-reduced by 99% and has an intact cow’s milk as a protein source to help reduce fussiness and gas caused by lactose sensitivity.

Furthermore, SoothePRO is sugar-free and has a probiotic called Lactobacillus Reuteri (L. Reuteri) to help the digestive system. In contrast, Pro Sensitive is palm oil-free and has a blend of DHA, lutein, and vitamin E called OptiGro.

Image source: Nestle Health Science

In terms of price, Gerber Good Start SoothePro is cheaper (1.19 $/oz) than Pro Sensitive (1.24 $/oz) but it doesn’t have an RTF form. However, the latter is enriched with minerals more than SoothePRO.

Other than that, they are similar and have the same purpose.

Moms Reviews:

Similac Pro SensitiveGerber Good Start SoothePro
Positive
Reviews
Good for fussiness
Easy to digest
Good taste
Easy to mix
Huge container
It has a scoop holder
Good taste
Negative
Reviews
May cause constipation
May cause gas
Too foamy
Can cause gas and bloat
in some babies
Smelly poops

The table below shows a complete comparison between Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start SoothePro in terms of ingredients, features, nutrient value, and price.

Similac Pro SensitiveGerber Good Start SoothePro
Protein sourceMilk Protein IsolatePartially hydrolyzed whey
protein concentrate
Whey to Casein Ratio18:82100% whey
Carbohydrate source 1% Lactose
Corn Syrup
Sugar
70% Lactose
30% Maltodextrin
Fat source– High Oleic Safflower Oil
– Soy Oil
– Coconut Oil
– DHA/ARA
40% Palm Oil
6% High Oleic Safflower Oil
34% Soy Oil
18% Coconut Oil
2% single cell oil
DHA/ARA
Extra FeaturesOptiGro
Prebiotics– 2′-FL HMO
Short-chain Fructooligosaccharides
2′-FL HMO
ProbioticsL. Reuteri
Generic Brands7 Generic brands6 Generic brands
Protein (g)2.1 /100 Cal2.2 /100 Cal
Fat (g)5.4 /100 Cal5.1 /100 Cal
Carbohydrate (g)10.9 /100 Cal11.2 /100 Cal
Vitamin A (IU)300 /100 Cal300 /100 Cal
Vitamin D (IU)60 /100 Cal60 /100 Cal
Vitamin E (IU)1.5 /100 Cal2 /100 Cal
Vitamin C (mg)
(Ascorbic acid)
9 /100 Cal10 /100 Cal
Inositol (mg)24 /100 Cal6 /100 Cal
Calcium (mg)84 /100 Cal72 /100 Cal
Phosphorus (mg)56 /100 Cal40 /100 Cal
Iron (mg)1.8 /100 Cal1.5 /100 Cal
Zinc (mg)0.75 /100 Cal0.8 /100 Cal
Manganese (mcg)5 /100 Cal15 /100 Cal
Sodium (mg)30 /100 Cal27 /100 Cal
Source of ARAMortierella alpina oilMortierella alpina oil
Source of DHACrypthecodinium cohnii oilCrypthecodinium cohnii oil
Size and Price29.8 oz
36.96 $
1.24 /oz

32 fl oz
8.12$
25.4 ¢/fl oz
12.4 oz
18.78 $
1.52 /oz

19.4 oz
29.53$
1.52 /oz

30.6 oz
36.48 $
1.19 /oz
Rating4.3 of 5.0
895 reviews
4.5 of 5.0
259 reviews
Ready-to-feedYesNo
Where to Buy?Buy 29.8 oz HERE

Buy Ready-to-feed
Buy 12.4 oz HERE

Buy 19.4 oz HERE

Buy 30.6 oz HERE
Overall Note7.5/108/10
Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start SoothePro

Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start Gentle:

Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start Gentle

There is a big difference between Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start Gentle because they have different purposes; the latter is a regular milk-based formula designed for babies with no sensitivity or allergy issues made from nonfat milk plus whey protein concentrate and 100% lactose whereas Similac Pro Sensitive is a lactose-reduced formula by 99% designed to reduce fussiness and gas caused by lactose sensitivity.

Similac Pro SensitiveGerber Good Start Gentle
Positive
Reviews
Good for fussiness
Easy to digest
Good taste
Good for gas
Good taste
It has a probiotic
Easy to mix
Less fussiness
Negative
Reviews
May cause constipation
May cause gas
Too foamy
The scoop is too wide
No RTF form

Can you switch between Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start Gentle?

In case your baby is on Gerber Good Start Gentle and shows bad reactions due to lactose sensitivity, then it’s recommended to switch to lactose-reduced or lactose-free formula. Hypoallergenic formulas are expensive so the first thing to do is switch to a lactose-reduced formula like Similac Sensitive, Pro Sensitive, Total Comfort, or Pro Total Comfort… give it some time and see his reactions.

There are a lot of alternatives to Similac Pro Sensitive to try, check these articles where I did a full comparison between Similac Pro Sensitive and all Enfamil Formulas, also between Similac Pro Sensitive and all Similac Formulas to help choose the right alternatives.

The table below shows a complete comparison between Similac Pro Sensitive and Gerber Good Start Gentle in terms of ingredients, features, nutrient value, and price.

Similac Pro SensitiveGerber Good Start Gentle
Protein sourceMilk Protein IsolateNonfat Milk
Whey Protein Concentrate
Whey to Casein Ratio18:8270:30
Carbohydrate source 1% Lactose
Corn Syrup
Sugar
100% Lactose
Fat source– High Oleic Safflower Oil
– Soy Oil
– Coconut Oil
– DHA/ARA
40% Palm Oil
6% High Oleic Safflower Oil
35% Soy Oil
18% Coconut Oil
0.32% DHA/ARA
Extra FeaturesOptiGro
Prebiotics– 2′-FL HMO
Short-chain Fructooligosaccharides
2′-FL HMO
ProbioticsB. Lactis
Generic Brands7 Generic brands9 Generic brands
Protein (g)2.1 /100 Cal2.1 /100 Cal
Fat (g)5.4 /100 Cal5.1 /100 Cal
Carbohydrate (g)10.9 /100 Cal11.4 /100 Cal
Vitamin A (IU)300 /100 Cal300 /100 Cal
Vitamin D (IU)60 /100 Cal65 /100 Cal
Vitamin E (IU)1.5 /100 Cal2 /100 Cal
Vitamin C (mg)
(Ascorbic acid)
9 /100 Cal10 /100 Cal
Inositol (mg)24 /100 Cal6 /100 Cal
Calcium (mg)84 /100 Cal67 /100 Cal
Phosphorus (mg)56 /100 Cal38 /100 Cal
Iron (mg)1.8 /100 Cal1.5 /100 Cal
Zinc (mg)0.75 /100 Cal0.8 /100 Cal
Manganese (mcg)5 /100 Cal15 /100 Cal
Sodium (mg)30 /100 Cal27 /100 Cal
Source of ARAMortierella alpina oilMortierella alpina oil
Source of DHACrypthecodinium cohnii oilCrypthecodinium cohnii oil
Size and Price29.8 oz
36.96 $
1.24 /oz


32 fl oz
8.12$
25.4 ¢/fl oz
12.7 oz
18.78 $
1.48 /oz

27 oz
34.98 $
1.30 /oz
Rating4.3 of 5.0
895 reviews
4.6 of 5.0
1155 reviews
Ready-to-feedYesNo
Where to Buy?Buy 29.8 oz HERE

Buy Ready-to-feed
Buy 12.7oz HERE

Buy 27 oz HERE
Overall Note7.5/107.5/10
Similac Pro Sensitive vs Gerber Good Start Gentle

Final Thoughts:

The best alternative to Similac Pro Sensitive in the Gerber brand is Gerber Good Start GentlePRO and SoothePRO because they are of the same type (lactose-reduced formulas) and have the same nutrient value, although these late have more lactose than Pro Sensitive. But, they have a partially hydrolyzed whey protein to ease digestion for your baby.

Image Credit:

Versus Vectors by Vecteezy

Leave a Reply