Similac Pro Advance Vs All Gerber Good Start Formulas: Full Comparison

You are currently viewing Similac Pro Advance Vs All Gerber Good Start Formulas: Full Comparison

Similac Pro Advance is a regular milk-based formula designed for babies who have no allergy to lactose or intact cow’s milk. It’s made from nonfat milk, whey protein concentrate, and 100% lactose. Moreover, it’s palm oil-free and has two prebiotics to help promote gut health. Also, it has the OptiGro feature (a blend of DHA, lutein, and vitamin E) to help eye, brain, and cell development.

In this article, we will see a full comparison between Similac Pro Advance and all Gerber formulas. Stay with me!

“When you buy something using my links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This is a kind of support to me. This website doesn’t accept money for reviews. “

Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start Gentle:

Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start Gentle

Similac Pro Advance and Gerber Good Start Gentle are standard milk-based formulas for babies with no sensitivity issues made from nonfat milk, whey protein concentrate, and 100% lactose. The difference between them is that Gerber Good Start Gentle has the B. Lactis probiotic and whey to casein ratio of 70:30. Also it has a low level of iron (1.5 mg/100 Cal). In contrast, Pro Advance has 48:52. Moreover, Similac Pro Advance contains the OptiGro feature which is a blend of DHA, lutein, and vitamin E for eye, brain, and cell development. Also, it’s palm oil-free.

Moreover, the Gerber Good Start Gentle formula has more vitamins and minerals than Pro Advance. However, Good Start Gentle doesn’t have a ready-to-feed form.

The ratio of whey to casein in breastmilk is 70% to 30% and 80% to 20% in early lactation and decreases to 50% to 50% in late lactation because the whey protein is easily digested by the body while the casein becomes curds in the stomach and take time to be digested. So, in terms of whey-to-casein ratio, Gerber Good Start Gentle is the closest one to breastmilk.

Prebiotics are food for probiotics (good bacteria), they promote their growth to keep the digestive system clean and healthy.

« HMOs are special prebiotics found naturally in a mother’s breast milk. They are the most abundant solid ingredient in breast milk after fat and carbohydrates. In breastfed babies, HMOs are scientifically shown to positively affect the microbiome. » says nutritionnews.Abbott

Moms Reviews:

Similac Pro AdvanceGerber Good Start Gentle
Positive
Reviews
Good taste
Available in RTF
Good for gas
Good taste
It has a probiotic
Easy to mix
Less fussiness
Negative
Reviews
May cause gasThe scoop is too wide
No RTF form

Can I switch between Similac Pro Advance and Gerber Good Start Gentle:

Yes, your baby can take Gerber Good Start Gentle and Similac Pro Advance interchangeably because they have the same protein, and carbohydrate sources so they have the same purpose. The absence of extra features like prebiotics/probiotics or the difference in vitamin and mineral levels doesn’t impact your baby’s health.

This table shows a full comparison between Pro Advance and Good Start Gentle, for a better view rotate your phone screen.

Similac Pro AdvanceGerber Good Start Gentle
Protein sourceNonfat Milk
Whey Protein Concentrate
Nonfat Milk
Whey Protein Concentrate
Whey to Casein Ratio48:5270:30
Carbohydrate source 100% Lactose100% Lactose
Fat source– High Oleic Safflower Oil
– Soy Oil
– Coconut Oil
– DHA/ARA
40% Palm Oil
6% High Oleic Safflower Oil
35% Soy Oil
18% Coconut Oil
0.32% DHA/ARA
Extra FeaturesOptiGro
Prebiotics2′-FL HMO
Short-chain Fructooligosaccharides
2′-FL HMO
ProbioticsB. Lactis
Generic Brands9 Generic brands9 Generic brands
Protein (g)2.07 /100 Cal2.1 /100 Cal
Fat (g)5.6 /100 Cal5.1 /100 Cal
Carbohydrate (g)10.7 /100 Cal11.4 /100 Cal
Vitamin A (IU)300 /100 Cal300 /100 Cal
Vitamin D (IU)60 /100 Cal65 /100 Cal
Vitamin E (IU)1.5 /100 Cal2 /100 Cal
Vitamin C (mg)
(Ascorbic acid)
9 /100 Cal10 /100 Cal
Inositol (mg)24 /100 Cal6 /100 Cal
Calcium (mg)78 /100 Cal67 /100 Cal
Phosphorus (mg)42 /100 Cal38 /100 Cal
Iron (mg)1.8 /100 Cal1.5 /100 Cal
Zinc (mg)0.75 /100 Cal0.8 /100 Cal
Manganese (mcg)5 /100 Cal15 /100 Cal
Sodium (mg)24 /100 Cal27 /100 Cal
Source of ARAMortierella alpina oilMortierella alpina oil
Source of DHASchizochytrium Sp. oilCrypthecodinium cohnii oil
Size and Price30.8 oz
37.48 $
1.22 /oz

32-fl oz
10.42$
32.6 ¢/fl oz
12.7 oz
18.78 $
1.48 /oz

27 oz
34.98 $
1.30 /oz
Rating4.5 of 5.0
665 reviews
4.6 of 5.0
1155 reviews
Ready-to-feedYesNo
Where to Buy?Buy 30.8 oz HERE

Buy Ready-to-feed
Buy 12.7oz HERE

Buy 27 oz HERE
Overall Note7.5/107.5/10
Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start Gentle

Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start GentlePro:

Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start GentlePro:

The difference between Similac Pro Advance and Gerber Good Start GentlePro is that each one has a different purpose; the latter is designed for babies with intact cow’s milk protein and lactose sensitivity by chopping the whey protein concentrate a little bit in size to be gentle on babies tummy and reducing lactose by 30% whereas Similac Pro Advance is a regular milk-based formula made from intact cow’s milk and 100% lactose.

Moms Reviews:

Similac Pro AdvanceGerber Good Start GentlePro
Positive
Reviews
Good taste
Available in RTF
Good for Gas
Easy to mix
Huge container
It has a scoop holder
Good taste
Negative
Reviews
May cause gasNot good for traveling
The scoop is too wide

Can I switch between Similac Pro Advance and Gerber Good Start GentlePro:

Switching from standard milk-based to partially hydrolyzed formula is safe and recommended in case your baby has bad reactions to those regular formulas. However, doing the opposite while your LO still has intact cow’s milk or lactose sensitivity is not recommended, instead, you must switch to a more gentle and sensitive formula.

This table shows a full comparison between Pro Advance and Good Start GentlePro, for a better view rotate your phone screen.

Similac Pro AdvanceGerber Good Start GentlePro
Protein sourceNonfat Milk
Whey Protein Concentrate
Partially hydrolyzed whey
protein concentrate
Whey to Casein Ratio48:52100% whey
Carbohydrate source 100% Lactose70% Lactose
30% Maltodextrin
Fat source– High Oleic Safflower Oil
– Soy Oil
– Coconut Oil
– DHA/ARA
38% Palm Oil
6% High Oleic Safflower Oil
35% Soy Oil
19% Coconut Oil
2% single cell oil
DHA/ARA
Extra FeaturesOptiGro
Prebiotics2′-FL HMO
Short-chain Fructooligosaccharides
2′-FL HMO
ProbioticsB. Lactis
Generic Brands9 Generic brands6 Generic brands
Protein (g)2.07 /100 Cal2.2 /100 Cal
Fat (g)5.6 /100 Cal5.1 /100 Cal
Carbohydrate (g)10.7 /100 Cal11.2 /100 Cal
Vitamin A (IU)300 /100 Cal300 /100 Cal
Vitamin D (IU)60 /100 Cal75 /100 Cal
Vitamin E (IU)1.5 /100 Cal2 /100 Cal
Vitamin C (mg)
(Ascorbic acid)
9 /100 Cal10 /100 Cal
Inositol (mg)24 /100 Cal6 /100 Cal
Calcium (mg)78 /100 Cal67 /100 Cal
Phosphorus (mg)42 /100 Cal38 /100 Cal
Iron (mg)1.8 /100 Cal1.5 /100 Cal
Zinc (mg)0.75 /100 Cal0.8 /100 Cal
Manganese (mcg)5 /100 Cal15 /100 Cal
Sodium (mg)24 /100 Cal27 /100 Cal
Source of ARAMortierella alpina oilMortierella alpina oil
Source of DHASchizochytrium Sp. oilCrypthecodinium cohnii oil
Size and Price30.8 oz
37.48 $
1.22 /oz

32-fl oz
10.42$
32.6 ¢/fl oz
20 oz
29.24 $
1.46 /oz

32 oz
36.48 $
1.14 /oz

33.8 fl oz
8.74$
25.9 ¢/fl oz
Rating4.5 of 5.0
665 reviews
4.8 of 5.0
2519 reviews
Ready-to-feedYesYes
Where to Buy?Buy 30.8 oz HERE

Buy Ready-to-feed
Buy 20 oz HERE

Buy 32 oz HERE

Buy RTF HERE
Overall Note7.5/108/10
Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start GentlePro

Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start SoothePro:

Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start SoothePro

The difference between Similac Pro Advance and Gerber Good Start SoothePro is that each one is made to fill a need; the latter is designed to help babies with gas, crying, and hard stools due to intact cow’s milk protein and lactose sensitivity by chopping the whey protein concentrate a little bit in size to be gentle on babies tummy and reducing lactose by 30% whereas Similac Pro Advance is a regular milk-based formula made from intact cow’s milk and 100% lactose.

Similac Pro AdvanceGerber Good Start SoothePro
Positive
Reviews
Good taste
Available in RTF
Easy to mix
Huge container
It has a scoop holder
Good taste
Negative
Reviews
May cause gasCan cause gas and bloat
in some babies
Smelly poops

Can I switch between Similac Pro Advance and Gerber Good Start SoothePro:

Switching from Similac Pro Advance to Gerber Good Start SoothePro is safe, but doing the opposite is not recommended if your baby still has an allergy to lactose or intact cow’s milk. In case your LO has no sensitivity issues then he can take both formulas interchangeably.

This table shows a full comparison between Pro Advance and Good Start SoothePro, for a better view rotate your phone screen.

Similac Pro AdvanceGerber Good Start SoothePro
Protein sourceNonfat Milk
Whey Protein Concentrate
Partially hydrolyzed whey
protein concentrate
Whey to Casein Ratio48:52100% whey
Carbohydrate source 100% Lactose70% Lactose
30% Maltodextrin
Fat source– High Oleic Safflower Oil
– Soy Oil
– Coconut Oil
– DHA/ARA
40% Palm Oil
6% High Oleic Safflower Oil
34% Soy Oil
18% Coconut Oil
2% single cell oil
DHA/ARA
Extra FeaturesOptiGro
Prebiotics2′-FL HMO
Short-chain Fructooligosaccharides
2′-FL HMO
ProbioticsL. Reuteri
Generic Brands9 Generic brands6 Generic brands
Protein (g)2.07 /100 Cal2.2 /100 Cal
Fat (g)5.6 /100 Cal5.1 /100 Cal
Carbohydrate (g)10.7 /100 Cal11.2 /100 Cal
Vitamin A (IU)300 /100 Cal300 /100 Cal
Vitamin D (IU)60 /100 Cal60 /100 Cal
Vitamin E (IU)1.5 /100 Cal2 /100 Cal
Vitamin C (mg)
(Ascorbic acid)
9 /100 Cal10 /100 Cal
Inositol (mg)24 /100 Cal6 /100 Cal
Calcium (mg)78 /100 Cal72 /100 Cal
Phosphorus (mg)42 /100 Cal40 /100 Cal
Iron (mg)1.8 /100 Cal1.5 /100 Cal
Zinc (mg)0.75 /100 Cal0.8 /100 Cal
Manganese (mcg)5 /100 Cal15 /100 Cal
Sodium (mg)24 /100 Cal27 /100 Cal
Source of ARAMortierella alpina oilMortierella alpina oil
Source of DHASchizochytrium Sp. oilCrypthecodinium cohnii oil
Size and Price30.8 oz
37.48 $
1.22 /oz

32-fl oz
10.42$
32.6 ¢/fl oz
12.4 oz
18.78 $
1.52 /oz

19.4 oz
29.53$
1.52 /oz

30.6 oz
36.48 $
1.19 /oz
Rating4.5 of 5.0
665 reviews
4.5 of 5.0
259 reviews
Ready-to-feedYesNo
Where to Buy?Buy 30.8 oz HERE

Buy Ready-to-feed
Buy 12.4 oz HERE

Buy 19.4 oz HERE

Buy 30.6 oz HERE
Overall Note7.5/108/10
Similac Pro Advance vs Gerber Good Start SoothePro

Final Thoughts:

Among all these formulas, the best alternative to Pro Advance in the Gerber brand is Gerber Good Start Gentle because they are regular milk-based formulas made for babies with no health issues. In terms of price, Similac Pro Advance is slightly cheaper and has an RTF form.

The other Gerber formulas could be good alternatives to Pro Advance in case your baby has an allergy to lactose or the intact cow’s milk protein.

Credit:

Versus Vectors by Vecteezy

Leave a Reply